Jubilee Scotland

  • Home
  • About us
    • Our story
    • Our Vision & Values
    • The Jubilee Scotland Team
    • Board Members
    • Our Funders and Networks
    • Annual reports
  • The Issue
    • The History of Debt in The Global South
    • Campaigning for cancellation
    • Guide to debt jargon
    • Country case studies
  • Campaigns
    • Scotland Against Public Private Partnerships (PPPs)
    • Scotland Against Climate Debt
    • Banks: Drop the Debt
    • Campaign successes
  • Get involved
    • Take Action
    • Donate
      • Donate as Individual
      • Organisations
    • Join the team
      • Jobs
      • Internship
      • Board of Directors
    • Become a member
  • Articles & Blogs
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Articles and Blogs / Defining illegitimate debt

Defining illegitimate debt

November 24, 2009 By picardo Leave a Comment

The problem of illegitimate debt is one of definition. Clearly we know that many – most even – of the debts owed by the poor countries of the world are bad, that they violate jus cogens, human rights, the peremptory norms of international law. Clearly we know that  by any reasonable moral standard, the loans extended to leaders like Mobutu and Marcos – with full knowledge of their misdeeds – should be cancelled without question, alongside those which were for projects that could never have been built, or loans which could never realistically have been repaid, or loans which simply disappeared into Swiss accounts. But nobody could argue that all debts were bad but before taking up the loan one must check this page to know whether you are eligible for a loan or not to avoid any kind of crisis in the future.

The problem is not therefore one of morality – the moral argument is black and white – but one of definition. Creditors have complex systems for defining and measuring concepts such as sustainability or payability, but how can we approach them asking for cancellation on the basis of legitimacy when there is no collectively agreed definition for that term? In this context the power to define becomes highly political. As one famous radical said: ‘Power is the ability to define things and have them react accordingly.’

The World Bank does an awful lot of defining. EUROAD, the European Network for Debt and Development, recently circulated a World Bank formula for establishing whether or not a debt was odious (a narrow subset of illegitimacy).

This excerpt shows – rather like Swift’s Laputa – how defining things bureaucratically tends to lead us quite quickly into the absurd. A juridical method for defining legitimacy – while producing an outcome that would probably satisfy nobody wholly – would at least create a definition that was meaningful enough to ground a productive debate. And with the bad debts still being collected, it’s vital that that debate happens soon.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up for our e-news updates

Past newsletters

Tag cloud

arms trade Climate Debt climate justice cop26 COP27 covid-19 debt debt campaigns debt cancellation debt justice debt relief DFID Edinburgh EURODAD european services strategy unit G8 G8 Watch Gleneagles HIPC IMF Jubilee Scotland Jubilee South Make Poverty History MDRI MSP Non-profit distributing NPD PFI Philippines poverty PPP PPPs Private Finance Initiative private financing protest public alternative public finance public private partnerships public services SAPPP Scotland scottish government UK World Bank Zambia

News

We’re closing but we’re celebrating the incredible work!

We are very sad to announce that Jubilee Scotland is closing its doors on the 31st of December 2023. It’s been a fantastic run and we are incredibly proud of the work we have done together. We cannot thank you enough for your support, whether you’ve given your time, finances or helped spread the word […]

Tweets by jubileescotland

Get in touch

Jubilee Scotland is an independent coalition of organisations and local groups across Scotland who campaign for cancellation of the unjust and unpayable debts which are ruining the world’s poorest countries.

JUBILEE SCOTLAND
41 GEORGE IV BRIDGE
EDINBURGH
SCOTLAND
EH1 1EL

T: 0131 225 4321
E: mail@jubileescotland.org.uk

Take action here!

  • Accessibility
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy and Cookies

Scottish Charity Number: SC031827 Company Number: SC220549

Copyright © 2023 Jubilee Scotland · Site built by graphics.coop · Powered by WordPress