• Home
  • About us
    • Our Vision & Values
    • The Jubilee Scotland Team
    • Board Members
    • Jobs and volunteering
    • Annual reports
    • Contact
  • The Issue
    • History of Debt
    • Campaigning for cancellation
    • Guide to debt jargon
    • Country case studies
  • Campaigns
    • Campaign successes
    • Rethinking Private Financing in Scotland
    • Open the books on PFI!
    • Defuse the debt crisis
    • Debt Cancellation for Nepal
    • Build a Movement
  • Get involved
    • Sign the debt justice pledge
    • Donate
    • Events
    • Become a member
    • Resources
      • Order form
    • Find campaign groups
  • Articles & Blogs
You are here: Home / Articles and Blogs / On reading ‘I.O.U.’ by Noreen Hertz

On reading ‘I.O.U.’ by Noreen Hertz

June 29, 2009 By picardo Leave a Comment

David was on the phone to Noreena Hertz’s agent the other day, trying to get her to speak on debt at one of the G20 events at St Andrews later in the year. I think the conversation was going really well until they started talking about costs! Anyway, you have to aim high… Overhearing the chat inspired me to get I.O.U. off the shelf – a book which I should probably have read five years ago. Rightly or wrongly we tend to regard 2005 as a water-shed year, but much of this book still seemed extremely up to date. One of the sections that most intrigued me was the last chapter, where she looked at solutions to what she refers to as the ‘holocaust’ of  international debt poverty. Plenty here to disagree with and inspire debate (nobody still thinks the IMF should be arbiter of it’s own cases, do they?) but one of the sections that gave me the most optimism was when she described two of the main obstacles standing in the way of Fair and Transparent Arbitration:

‘First, commercial and investment banks don’t want to see it happen. If it did, not only would they see some of their existing debts written down, they would also see the value of any relevant bonds that they or their clients were holding slashed. Their opposition has been completely unambiguous. An alliance of banks including Citigroup, JP Morgan Chase, UBS and Deutschebank responded to the IMF’s SDRM proposal with a statement to the effect that the plan was unworkable in any form. ‘no changes in any specific aspect of the plan’ would alter their ‘serious concern about the proposal,’ the banks said. And they wield immense political clout.

‘Second, despite Paul O’Neill’s support for a bankruptcy-type procedure while he was still in office, no one within the Bush Administration has got behind the idea since his abrupt resignation in December 2002. This is not surprising, given that all variants of this plan would entail the US handing over the de facto control it enjoys through the World Bank and the IMF  to a neutral authority. Multilateralism, as we all know, has not been high up the Bush Administration’s agenda.’ [Hertz, IOU, Harper Collins, 2004]

Reading this power analysis it occurred to me that both of these factors have changed – and changed in our favour. Clearly we have an administration in the US with a greater sympathy for multilateralism (as well as one which – thanks I’m sure to Jubilee USA – has already made a commitment to tackling the issue of odious debt). And as for the banks… well, they owe us one, don’t they? In fact, they owe us quite a few trillion…

Maybe one of the ways they could pay that back is by not interfering when we ask for an FTA?

James Picardo

Spread the word...Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someone

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sign up for our e-news updates

Blog Archive

Tag cloud

arms trade Brexit commonweal covid-19 debt debt campaigns debt cancellation debt justice debt relief dexter whitfield DFID Edinburgh EURODAD european services strategy unit G8 G8 Watch Gleneagles HIPC IMF Indonesia Jubilee Scotland Jubilee South local national partnership Make Poverty History MDRI MSP Non-profit distributing NPD ODA oxgangs school PFI pfis Philippines poverty PPP Private Finance Initiative private financing privatisation of life public private partnerships Public Works Loan Board robin mcalpine Scotland Suharto UK World Bank

News

Internship Opportunity, Autumn 2021

Jubilee Scotland has an exciting internship for a talented student to join us for the Autumn semester of 2021. This is a placement opportunity for students who undertake work experiences as part of their MSc degree.  About the internship  At Jubilee Scotland you will take part in the preparations for the UN Climate Summit in […]

Tweets by jubileescotland

Get in touch

Jubilee Scotland is an independent coalition of organisations and local groups across Scotland who campaign for cancellation of the unjust and unpayable debts which are ruining the world’s poorest countries.

JUBILEE SCOTLAND
41 GEORGE IV BRIDGE
EDINBURGH
SCOTLAND
EH1 1EL

T: 0131 225 4321
E: mail@jubileescotland.org.uk

  • Accessibility
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy and Cookies

Scottish Charity Number: SC031827 Company Number: SC220549

Copyright © 2021 Jubilee Scotland · Site built by graphics.coop · Powered by WordPress